Authored by the MyIT Tutor team, with editorial oversight from Frank Doogan.
Is online tutoring effective? Is one-to-one tutoring through a screen as good as having your tutor in the room? Here's a hint: it can be, and the tutor matters far more than the screen.
Is Online Tutoring Effective? The Stats
Always good to avoid conjecture and go with the facts, yes? Anyone can have an opinion about online tutoring, but the version that's been tested and measured should be the one we listen to, until it is falsified.
One-to-one tutoring is one of the best-evidenced interventions in education. Philip Oreopoulos, Professor of Economics and Public Policy at the University of Toronto, and his colleagues looked across 89 randomised trials of tutoring and found a pooled effect size of 0.288 SD, with the largest gains coming from programmes that use teachers or teaching assistants as tutors. That's the really important thought with your morning coffee: tutor quality is what changes the outcome, not the platform it's delivered on. Everything below only works if that condition is met.
The Flexibility Advantage: Benefits of Online Tutoring
- Lesson time set by the parent and student, not a school or centre timetable
- Zero commute: no arriving early, no traffic, no lost hour either side of the lesson
- A tutor chosen from a wide pool of quality-assured tutors, not whoever happens to be free at the local centre
- Full lesson content and resources shared live on-screen, extending what can be covered in the time available

The Internet Ease Myth: Disadvantages of Online Tutoring
Another myth worth naming honestly: that "online is always effortless". For most families with a stable connection and a decent device, it genuinely is: sit down, greet your tutor, start.
But it isn't universal. Lanndon Ocampo and his colleagues at Cebu Technological University in the Philippines reviewed 24 studies of online tutoring for pre-university students and found 13 recurring barriers, including unreliable connectivity and a lack of devices.
What actually closes this gap is a tutor and a provider who test the connection, have a backup ready, and troubleshoot fast so a glitch never eats into lesson time.
The Attendance Myth: Online Tutoring vs In-Person
Here's a myth that needs correcting, not repeating: that online is automatically "easier to attend, so more frequent". The best controlled evidence says otherwise. Shirin Hashim and her colleagues studied a summer reading programme in which the same tutors taught some children in person and others remotely, and found that in-person sessions had higher attendance.
Jennifer Krajewski, director of outreach and engagement at Proven Tutoring, put it plainly: "When it's a physical person in the building, they can pull you out of class. It's harder to avoid."
But wait, there's more! 😊
Other research shows the gap can be closed with structure rather than convenience. Amanda Neitzel, assistant research scientist at the Center for Research and Reform in Education at Johns Hopkins University, and a colleague evaluated a virtual reading programme in which first-grade students had daily 15-minute one-to-one sessions, five days a week, with attendance recorded for every session. Of 1,872 students, 1,545 attended more than 85% of their sessions. So attendance depends less on the format and more on the routine built around it.
1,545 of 1,872 students attended more than 85% of their sessions: daily one-to-one virtual reading tutoring (Neitzel and Reilly, 2024)
The Rapport Myth
It is not a myth that good rapport can form online: students and tutors absolutely build real trust and warmth through a screen. What the evidence does show is that it takes a touch more deliberate effort than face-to-face. In the same summer reading study, tutors reported closer relationships with their in-person students, even though there was no statistically significant difference in the children's reading results either way. Translation: the connection is real, it just doesn't form itself. A tutor has to build it on purpose.
The Comfort Reality
Home removes the discomfort of walking into an unfamiliar group setting after a long school day. That's real, and it matters for some students. It's also fair to say home isn't a distraction-free zone: siblings, notifications and phones are all close by. A quiet, dedicated space, agreed with the tutor in advance, is what turns "familiar" into "focused".

How to Make Online Tutoring Work: Your Requirements
None of the above happens by accident. If you want the online advantage without the online risk:
- Insist on a quality-assured tutor: this is the one variable the research says matters most
- Fix a consistent day and time, and protect it like you would a school lesson
- Set up a quiet, dedicated study space, free of siblings, phones, and notifications
- Ask for a lesson report after every session, whether or not something has gone wrong
- Test the tech before the first lesson, and know the backup plan if it fails
So, Online Tutoring vs In-Person: Which Wins?
Online one-to-one tutoring isn't automatically better, and it isn't automatically worse.
With an exceptional, trained tutor and the right structure around it, it can match what a local tutorial centre can offer. And in practical ways, such as no travel, more family flexibility and less exposure to illness, it can go further.
At MyIT, we show you matching tutors and you choose one, and every tutor is quality assured by Train The Teacher.
So, choose your tutor, fix your time, clear your desk, and let the screen take care of the travel 😊